Emily Dickinson’s Coconut Cake

Emily Dickinson's  coconut cakeI had read somewhere that Emily Dickinson was a baker, but I somehow pictured the reclusive poet making only loaves of spartan bread. When I began reading about her cooking, however, I realized that my image of her was all wrong. She was a prolific and joyful baker, and she delighted in making not just bread (and very good bread) but also puddings, cakes, gingerbread, and candies.

In 1845, the 14-year-old Emily wrote her friend Abiah Root, “I am going to learn to make bread to-morrow. So you may imagine me with my sleeves rolled up, mixing flour, milk, salaratus, etc., with a great deal of grace.” A decade later, Dickinson’s “rye and Indian” bread won a prize at a local cattle show, and she was doing much of the baking for her family in Amherst, Massachusetts. But the poet’s passion for desserts is what really struck me. Her friend Thomas Wentworth Higginson wrote his wife that Dickinson told him, “People must have puddings,” and this was said to him “very dreamily,  as if they were comets — so she makes them.”


An 1846 or 1847 daguerreotype of Emily Dickinson.

Dickinson seems to have found poetic inspiration in the kitchen. While cooking, she sometimes wrote drafts of poems on scraps of paper, including the backs of recipes, shopping lists, and even the wrapper for a bar of Parisian baking chocolate.

She often discussed baking in her letters, and her language about food was passionate and playful. In one letter, she wrote that she was “pleased the Gingerbread triumphed,” while another referred to “the glory” of two loaves of bread.

Dickinson loved to bake for others and kept doing so even after she stopped leaving her home. She sent cakes and candies to neighbors and friends, and she would lower baskets filled with cake or gingerbread from her window to children in the street below. Not exactly what one would expect of a recluse!

Dickinson had two recipes for coconut cake. One was from her neighbor Mrs. Carmichael,  on the back of which Emily wrote a poem (“The things that never can come back, are several –”). Another was found inside a first-edition book of Dickinson letters. I think the Carmichael recipe is older, as it contained no chemical leaveners, just many more eggs. Here is an image of the second recipe, followed by an easier-to-read transcription:

President and Fellows of Harvard College, Emily Dickinson's Coconut cake recipe.

President and Fellows of Harvard College, Emily Dickinson’s Coconut cake recipe.

1 cup cocoanut
2 cups flour
1 cup sugar
1/2 cup butter
1/2 cup milk
2 eggs
1/2 teaspoonful soda
1 teaspoonful cream of tartar
This makes one half the rule–

I wanted to show the original recipe so that readers can see Dickinson’s wonderful curlicued “c’s”. Note also the spelling “cocoanut,” a confusion of coconut with cocoa that apparently started with an entry in Samuel Johnson’s 1755 Dictionary and continued for centuries. The reference to “half the rule” at the end means that the ingredients are enough for half a cake, so the size of a loaf pan.

Coconuts were common enough in North America by the mid-19th century to be available even in small towns in Massachusetts. They were shipped from Cuba and elsewhere in the West Indies and the Caribbean. John Mariani’s Dictionary of American Food and Drink dates coconut cake to 1830, though I think coconut pie (then called “pudding”) was more common until later in the century. Dried, flaked coconut wasn’t available, however, until the 1890s, so baking with the fruit required more work.

I am the lone coconut fan in a household of coconut haters, but I couldn’t resist making this recipe. Although it listed only ingredients, not directions, it seemed easy enough. I read on several blogs (including Tori Avey’s excellent History Kitchen) that this cake was good but a little heavy, so I tried it with cake flour instead of all-purpose. I also used sweetened flaked coconut instead of a raw coconut (yes, I know, not authentic, but so much easier).

There were no icing instructions for this cake. It was meant to be a simple loaf cake, not the coconut layer cake we think of today, covered with fluffy frosting (that’s a Southern tradition). This one really doesn’t need icing, however — it’s rich with butter and coconut, and is just sweet enough. I think, as Dickinson might have said, that it triumphed!

coconut cake batter

Emily Dickinson’s Coconut Cake
Adapted from a recipe in the collection of Donald and Patricia Oresman

½ cup (4 ounces) unsalted butter, room temperature
1 cup sugar
2 eggs, lightly beaten
2 cups cake flour
½ teaspoon baking soda
1 teaspoon cream of tartar
½ cup whole milk, room temperature
1 cup sweetened flaked coconut

1. Preheat the oven to 350°F. Grease an 8½″ X 4½″ loaf pan with butter, line the bottom with parchment, and butter the parchment.

2. In a large bowl, beat the butter and sugar together until light and creamy. Add the eggs and beat well.

3. Sift the cake flour together with the baking soda and cream of tartar, and whisk to blend (or substitute a scant 2 teaspoons of baking powder for the soda and cream of tartar).

4. Add half the milk to the butter-sugar mixture and stir to blend, then add half the flour mixture and mix well. Add the remaining milk and then the remaining flour, mixing briefly after each addition. Fold in the coconut.

5. Pour batter into the prepared pan. Bake on middle rack of oven for about 55-60 minutes, until golden around the edges and a cake tester or toothpick comes out clean. Let rest in pan for 10 minutes, then turn out onto a rack and let cool completely.


27 thoughts on “Emily Dickinson’s Coconut Cake

    • The recipe was exhibited in a show at Poets House in New York City a few years ago and I believe is in the public domain. BTW, I love your post on baking powder bread. Seven teaspoons of baking powder!

  1. I love this post because I’ve been baking Emily’s Black Cake since I played her in Belle of Amherst at a local theater more than 20 years ago. Last year I also tried the coconut cake recipe and loved it. Like you, I’m the only coconut nut in my family, but that’s quite alright.
    If you want to read my thoughts on the Black Cake, here’s one of several posts I have done on it. http://ancestorsinaprons.com/2013/12/emily-dickinson-black-cake/ The Dickinson museum published a book of her recipes, which is out of print. There is another book about her as a cook and I hope to find both one of these days.

    • Your black cake looks incredible, Vera! I do want that Dickinson Museum book. In the meantime, I’m going to make black cake one of these days, and BTW, I’m under strict orders not to use my husband’s best brandy. 😉

  2. I made Emily Dickinson’s black cake for a literary party but I didn’t know of her extensive interest in cooking. Thanks for posting the original, handwritten recipe! Next time, if you want unsweetened coconut flakes, look at a natural foods store. Those may be closer to what Emily would have made.

  3. Pingback: In My Pastry Kitchen | My Kitchen Witch

  4. I’ve baked Emily’s Rice Cake — a wonderful cake, and it happens to be gluten-free, and not contain any “weird” ingredients — but I’ve never made her Cocoanut Cake. I’ll have to try it later this year! It looks like it would be a perfect thing for Easter. I’ve been meaning to make her Gingerbread for the holidays, too. I wish more of her recipes were available! A whole cookbook, maybe?

    • I saw that rice cake recipe — it sounds interesting. I think the coconut cake would be wonderful for Easter! FYI, there is a pamphlet with some Dickinson recipes available from the shop at the Emily Dickinson Museum in Amherst (emilydickinsonmuseum.org). I couldn’t get ahold of it because the museum is closed in winter, but I think it may have reopened this month. As for a whole cookbook, I’m not sure there is enough original material.

      • Hmm, I’ll have to check out the museum website then. I’ve seen only a few of her recipes online, so I wasn’t sure if someone had published a collection of them.

    • Your cousin’s novel sounds really interesting — thanks for the link! While working on this post, I read about the nonfiction book Maid as Muse, about Margaret Maher and other servants in Emily’s household. Good luck with the cake, and I hope it comes out well.

  5. Both cocoanut cake recipes contain chemical leaveners: cream of tartar and baking soda. Each will leaven independently; together they are baking powder.

  6. Pingback: [review + recipe] On Wings of Words by Jennifer Berne and Becca Stadtlander | Jama's Alphabet Soup

Leave a Reply to Holistic Wayfarer Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s